Inside the Labyrinth: Osler's Web Updates

Dr. LUCINDA BATEMEN'S COMMENTS AT THE RECENT CFSAC MEETING AS HER TERM ENDS:

November 11, 2009

Tags: DR. BATEMEN'S CFASC TERM HAS ENDED; SHE SAYS GOOD-BYE TO THE COMMITTEE

Almost 20 years ago, when I finished my residency, the Infectious Disease fellows placed a message on the telephone saying, “If you are calling about Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, call Dr. Bateman at this number,” essentially diverting CFS patients away from the state funded university hospital to my new internal medicine practice.

It was a joke—payback--- for the intense interest I had expressed for CFS during my training, about the time the 1988 Holmes case definition was published. My interest was initially fueled by a personal desire to help my sister, who became ill while I was in medical school, but grew as I searched the medical literature, evaluated hundreds of patients, and came to know the illness face to face.

Nine years ago, after 10 years of CFS, my sister developed non-Hodgkins lymphoma. She died at age 51, overwhelmed by an unknown infection following stem cell transplant. Now WPI has reported the presence of XMRV, a discovery that could potentially have changed her fate.

Two decades after diagnosing my first patient, and one decade after opening a CFS clinic, remaining self employed has been the best way to continue a search for answers and to provide a place for patients with CFS.


I have indirectly donated at least a million dollars to the cause of CFS in the form of lost potential income.

I still participate in Medicare and most major insurances and follow a large group of patients with CFS and related illnesses. As a small business owner I can not provide medical insurance for my staff and was myself recently declined individual medical insurance by Blue Cross/Blue Shield. The clinic generally runs in the red and continues as a service to patients in my community.

The effort is subsidized largely by pharmaceutical dollars since I moonlight doing drug research and consulting to pay my clinical staff.

***


The CDC researchers are still doing epidemiology, deny a viral contribution, and demonstrate little understanding of the clinical subsets that meet the Fukuda CFS Case Definition

The NIH has not matched research funding to the significance and immediacy of the problem.

There is little recognition, interest or expertise regarding CFS at academic medical institutions across the country, including the University of Utah.


As a departing member of the CFSAC, I’m grateful for the chance to represent my CFS patients, to learn the ins and outs of Washington and to meet the many good people who form the committee. Thank you for your dedication and contributions. I’m happy for the progress that has been made.

I’m disappointed that the urgent and repeated recommendations of this committee for research funding, clinical care and CFS education—coming from people with the most CFS experience--- have largely fallen on deaf ears or been met with excuses and resistance.

I’m disappointed that federal agencies have been underfunded, uninspired, and generally disinterested in this urgent public health problem, and have maintained an undercurrent of disdain, not only for those who are ill, but also those who are trying to help them in the face of dismal resources.

I would like to thank all who have been working in the field for the last 20-plus years.

I sincerely hope that the discovery of XMRV in patients with CFS, along with other high quality but largely unnoticed recent biomarker research, will stimulate an explosion of good questions and additional science that will place all the patients with CFS back on the scientific radar and into the mainstream of modern medicine.

Lucinda Bateman, M.D.
October 30, 2009

Comments

  1. November 12, 2009 10:22 AM EST
    Thank you Dr. Bateman for all that you have done for the CFIDS community. It is greatly appreciated. It is the very few physicians like you that have kept many of us CFIDS sick from literally dying from other diseases masked by CFIDS and from the depression caused by having an odd disease that has been demeaned and denied by the medical community, the government, the public and our own family and friends. Without doctors like you, and you in particular, we CFIDS sick would have no one to help reduce our symptoms, listen to our cries, and knock themselves out to support us medically, politically, and in research arena.
    A Thank You isn't enough for your efforts in supporting us CFIDS sick. With great respect - Sharon Stapleton
    - sharon stapleton
  2. November 21, 2009 1:33 PM EST
    hi thank you from australia
    we are a me cfs fms mcs backwater i personally have gained knowledge and great emotional support from your web postings over the years since 2004 when my proffessor retired it is people like you that have kept us in the picture you may not have become as financially well off following the path you choose but god will remeber somewhere down the track good things will happen to you god bless geoffrey
    - Anonymous
  3. December 4, 2009 3:17 PM EST
    I second (or third, fourth, etc.) all of the heartfelt "thank you"'s volunteered so far. Dr. Bateman deserves all the accolades, now bypassed her, from her profession. I was a stranger in a strange land who landed in an Ampligen study at Dr. Bateman's clinic several years ago. Although the drug failed for me, I learned more about my disease than I had the previous seven years of being sick, largely because of her and the great people she surrounds herself with. Armed with the knowledge gleaned from her and her clinic, I was able to move back home and take my first real, painful, yet fruitful steps toward acceptance. Thank you for all of your work, doctor. You may have sacrificed much for the CFIDS community in this earthly realm, but I think that in some sphere beyond the material, you will be rightly recognized as having been a stable mountain in a desert of shifting sand that is the medical community writ large. Doing thankless work that other professionals could not, would not, were too timid, or were in search of the comforts available to them in our society, takes a person with a rare character and quality and can't be duplicated but only approximated. Thank you deeply for your work to date and what you will yet do for others. It really does matter!
    - Stephen Greer
  4. December 8, 2009 3:30 PM EST
    Thank you Dr. Bateman!!!
    - Justin Reilly

Three Million Dollars

To subscribe to this blog, please click on the RSS icon in your browser's web address bar when visiting the Blog page.




Response from the Centers for Disease Control to Osler’s Web upon its publication in 1996:

“…Tom Skinner, a spokesman for the CDC, said his agency has gotten numerous inquiries about the allegations raised in Ms. Johnson’s book but is neither investigating them nor commenting on them.

‘We have not reviewed her book, and will not comment on her book and are not going to,’ Skinner said.”

Dave Parks, Birmingham News, Birmingham, Alabama